Metafandom
- Seek
Tue, Jan. 5th, 2010, 04:25 pm
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
oula: Tuesday, January 5th, 2010
- zvi: That discussion about discussing fanwork - In the fandom of my dreams, critical discussion is for readers. In the same way that I tl;dr about Glee or Smallville or The X Files, I want to tl;dr about fan stories. I want to compare mpreg stories and tell you which is better and why. I want to deeply examine why I like some stories in the Ladies Choice collection and why some of them leave me cold. -
- toft: long necks, deep holes - It seems that a lot of all this is lumped together - people who are anti-Archive seem to also be anti-OTW and/or anti-Transformative Works and Cultures (the academic Fan Studies journal) and/or anti-acafan in general, often lumping those things together without any real sense of how they are distinguished from each other, or what they are really against. -
- morgandawn: What We Have Here Is A Failure To Communicate - Part 2 - What social contract do fans owe each other? Some fans feel that there should be laws or at the very least honorable agreements among fans on copying and storing fan fic, linking to websites, talking about fandom and fan fiction in public, and when to honor requests to remove fan fic and vids from public view. Others stare at you blankly when talking about "rules" and then flip you off. -
- cruiscin_lan: What makes YOU squick? - So basically, right now I'm looking for someone who can relate. What squicks you? Have you ever been squicked by a squick you didn't know you had? Have you gotten over squicks? Do you stop reading after hitting a squick, or do you try to skip it and keep going? Will you make exceptions based on author or other factors? -
- thelastgoodname: It occurs to me that an argument could be made.... - What if a person didn't want a future in which fannish activities were recognized as legal? What if said person liked doing things that are morally and legally dubious--what if that were part of the draw? What if the illegitimacy of the act were part of why a person participated? -